View photos

Menu Snapshot

Three Meat Pizza
Cheeses Burger
Chicken Philly Combo
Cheesesteak
  • Top categories (Appetizers / 16 Inch Specialty Pizza / Burgers / Salads / Sandwiches)
  • Most orders: $10–20
View Complete Menu

Overview & Highlights

If you're wandering through the charming town of Gatesville, North Carolina, let the allure of Will-O-Wisp Café be your guiding light. Located conveniently at 504 Main St, this café has quickly become a beloved local gem, enticing visitors with its unique blend of flavors and community spirit. With a phone call to +1 252-357-0144, you can inquire about their delectable offerings, but be prepared; it's challenging to leave without indulging in a bite or two!

The menu at Will-O-Wisp Café is a testament to comfort food done right. Start your experience with tempting appetizers like crispy fries or garlic knots, perfect for sharing—or devouring solo if you prefer! The Philly Cheese Fries have garnered recommendations from satisfied patrons, and the onion rings add a delightful crunch to any meal.

Your main course options hold their own with a selection of hearty burgers, including the classic hamburger and cheeseburger, catering to both savory cravings and adventurous eateries alike. The double cheeseburger, noted by customers for its rich taste, is a must-try alongside their signature pizza, which is renowned for being hot and fresh.

As you enjoy your meal, you'll find that Will-O-Wisp Café isn't just a place for food; it's a vibrant space that welcomes fun. Guests can engage in lively BINGO nights or dive into an array of board games, as mentioned by several patrons who appreciate the café's community-focused environment. The extensive drink offerings, from bottled water to energizing drinks, meaning there’s something to complement every meal.

While some reviews hint at a need for staffing improvement, the overall atmosphere of Will-O-Wisp Café shines through its passion for great food and community connection. If you’re looking for a place that offers comfort, creativity, and camaraderie, this café might just be the perfect detour. So why not stop in, savor a slice of pizza, and enjoy a game or two? Your taste buds will thank you!

Comforts & Conveniences

Accessibility
  • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
  • Offers takeaway
  • Serves dine-in
  • No delivery
Popular for
  • Popular for lunch
  • Popular for dinner
  • Good for solo dining
Payments
  • Accepts credit cards

Where to Visit

Visitor Testimonials (288)

Today was a good prompt day for wil o wisp they do however need to offer the cheese steak loaded fries. I make myself from the sandwiche and fries combo. I love it. So good and the pizza was hot n fresh, a little pricey but that's ok. I didn't have to drive to Suffolk

Great place to play BINGO every Monday night. Every other Monday it's Tupperware Bingo. Their French fries are awesome! Pizza is good too!

They seem to be short staffed and having trouble with equipment. If they had so.e good help and income, they would be great for Gatesville. The pizza id delicious, and so was the Burger and Fries. The fries have that touch of batter. They also needed to have fresh ketchup

Stopped in today to grab something for dinner after a paddle up Bennets Creek. The menu has a good variety of items. Everything we had was great! I had a Italian sub, my wife got a burger and fries. We shared a pepperoni pizza. Our food was great, the fries were perfect! We would have taken pictures of all of our food if we didn't devour it so fast. They have a selection of demo board games to play. There are Star Wars, table top gaming supplies, board games and magic the gathering items for sale as well. We plan to stop in more often.

What a gem!!! I'm so glad that we stopped in here on our way to the state park! Absolutely incredible atmosphere and people - come for the pizza and find all the games! Wish we lived closer, may need to find a way to visit more!

Weekly live music, board games, and a really community center in addition to being a delightfully tasty cafe. The staff are friendly and helpful. The cheesy garlic bread is a must-have appetizer for me!

What a fun place! There are many boardgames and card games to play as you wait for your food. There are also roleplaying and expandable card games for sale. The pizza is crispy and generous with the toppings. Will-O-Wisp Cafe is perfect for family game night, or with friends.

Tell Us About Your Visit

Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *

Service & Hospitality
Value for Money
Food & Drink Quality
Ambience & Comfort

Explore Similar Places Nearby

O'Henry's Restaurant

10225 NC-67, East Bend, NC 27018, United States

  • 4.6 288 Ratings

33rd & Main

2121 Central Ave, Charlotte, NC 28205, United States

  • 4.6 240 Ratings

West A Street Grill

1503 W A St, Kannapolis, NC 28081, United States

  • 4.8 249 Ratings

Taqueria Monserrat

678 N Louisiana Ave, Asheville, NC 28806, United States

  • 4.2 290 Ratings

Coffee & Cream

3775 Concord Pkwy S Suite 116, Concord, NC 28027, United States

  • 4.9 396 Ratings

Tacos 3 Amigos

3762 Chimney Rock Rd, Hendersonville, NC 28792, United States

  • 4.3 239 Ratings

The Landing at Mackeys

417 Mackeys Ferry Rd, Roper, NC 27970, United States

  • 4.5 352 Ratings

Guerrero's

401 W Mills St, Columbus, NC 28722, United States

  • 4.9 304 Ratings

Casa Guerrero Mexican Food

109 N Railroad St, Magnolia, NC 28453, United States

  • 4.9 239 Ratings

Big Daddy's Fruits and Snacks

2190 Boone Trail, North Wilkesboro, NC 28659, United States

  • 4.9 233 Ratings

Discover More Places

Carnitas La Enrramada

21480, C. Quinta 70, Benito Juárez, Tecate, B.C., Mexico

  • 4.4 395 Ratings

Dafulan 大弗兰

Via Bologna, 31a, 10152 Torino TO, Italy

  • 4.9 302 Ratings

Bootlegger XS Cape Gate Halaal

Shop U79, Cnr Okavango &, Capegate Shopping Centre, De Bron Rd, Brackenfell, Cape Town, 7560, South Africa

  • 4.2 229 Ratings

Le Bon Coin

Rue des Paquis, 1201 Geneve, Switzerland

  • 4.4 242 Ratings

Pata De Vaca - Bar e Fogo

319 W - Av. das Águias - Bela Vista, Nova Mutum - MT, 78452-065, Brazil

  • 4.8 274 Ratings